Articles for ITS market ”Using a smartphone while driving” and “Level 3 automated driving”

 ”Using a smartphone while driving”, severe punishment and driver awareness

HMI is short for Human Machine Interface.
HMI in the automotive field often refers to the screen in the vehicle. In other words, emphasis is placed on human-car vision interfaces.
Under these circumstances issues that require fundamental discussions about ideal forms of HMI have emerged.

One issue is “using a smartphone while driving”, or operating your smartphone while driving.
The other is "secondary activity" in level 3 automated driving.

On December 1, 2019, the revised Road Traffic Law was enacted for “using a smartphone while driving” and penalties were tightened. Specifically, just holding a smartphone in your hand results in a jail sentence.
In addition, the number of violations in the event of an accident caused by “using a smartphone while driving” has tripled to six points and is subject to administrative license suspension.

However, when observing driving situations in the city after the law was amended we still see many people driving while using smartphones. In many cases they seem to be using social networking services such as LINE, Facebook, Twitter, email and games.
These situations are not only observed in Japan, but all over the world. There seems to be a very low individual awareness that they are doing dangerous acts that are punishable by law.

 Why CarPlay and Android Auto aren't popular

What do smartphone planners and manufacturers think about control by “using a smartphone while driving”?

Technically, Apple's CarPlay and Google's Android Auto which link the in-vehicle device and smartphone were mass-produced around 2015. The number of vehicles equipped with these technologies in North America has gradually been expanding. Along with this, “using a smartphone while driving” is on the decline, especially among younger generations. However, for cars manufactured before 2015 that support CarPlay and Android Auto, the "using a smartphone while driving" situations are routinely still the same and performed by all generations.

Actually in Japan the name CarPlay and Android Auto are not recognized at all.
There are fewer cars in Japan than in North America that can support CarPlay and Android Auto. But the reason is much different.

In Japan, car navigation systems became popular more than five years ago in the 1990s, compared to Europe and the United States. In-vehicle devices including the world's most advanced car navigation functions were mass-produced by Japanese manufacturers one after another. As a result, Japanese car navigation manufacturers were not aggressive in introducing CarPlay and Android Auto, which use the in-vehicle device as a "simple HMI."

However, automakers including Toyota's DCM (Data Communication Module), have begun to mass-produce connectivity technology R & D by circumventing car navigation manufacturers. Following Mazda Connect of Mazda, Toyota also introduced a display audio in the Corolla released in September 2019 with a common HMI. It is certain that this will be expanded to all Toyota models in the future.

With the business policies of automakers and car navigation manufacturers not being unified, the younger generation seems to feel that smartphones are easier to handle. After all, smartphones are more natural for them as an HMI.

 Discussion is needed between "using smartphone" and "automated driving" when considering human intervention.

"Using a smartphone while driving" is strictly prohibited, after revising the Road Traffic Law. However "using a smartphone while driving" is allowed under the same road traffic law for automated driving cars at level 3 and above.
There are five levels of automated driving, 1 to 5. In levels 1 and 2, driving is mainly performed by humans. In levels 3 to 5 the vehicle is the main driver.
At level 3 when the system determines that automated driving cannot be continued, such as in an emergency the system issues a TOR (Take Over Request) to the driver through voice, display, vibration, etc.
Until a TOR occurs the driver can perform actions other than driving without gazing forward, while maintaining a posture capable of returning to driving. This is called a secondary activity.

Secondary activities allow for eating and drinking, reading, and even smartphone operation. Therefore "driving while using a smartphone" is acceptable.
I've talked with carmakers and government agencies in various discussions about the challenges of introducing level 3 automated driving into society. In fact, I have driven on public roads with several level 3 automated driving test vehicles.
Based on such experience I believe that mass production of level 3 vehicles is extremely difficult from the perspective of social acceptability.

In mid-December 2019 there were reports that Honda will mass-produce level 3 automated vehicles for highway traffic congestion by the summer of 2020. “The wealthy people who can buy Level 3 self-driving cars can use smartphones "It is unfair to say that ordinary people who continue to drive older cars like us are not allowed to use smartphones.” These are some comments I sometimes see on the internet.

I agree with these opinions.
The relationship between “people and society” may change significantly due to automated driving and connectivity through communication. That is why it is necessary to discuss technology and law where people are prioritized, not technology.
I think society as a whole needs to think more deeply about the mismatch in HMI thinking between "using a smartphone while driving " and "level 3 automated driving".

Writer introduction

桃田 健史氏

Mr. Kenji Momota   Automotive journalist

His major is the world automotive industry and he is also familiar with the energy industry, IT and the aging society problem as the related fields. He acts around the world based in Japan and USA and writes for the general magazines, the technology journals and the automotive related media etc.
He is also commentator of motor race and world's motor show on TV program based on his career of the driver of Indy Racing League and NASCAR. In recent years, he has been covering about a paradigm shift from developed countries to developing countries, the motorized vehicle like EV and the telematics.